F1

21 to 29 of 29 messages
25/03/2013 at 14:12
the dude abides wrote (see)

glad to see that Vettel has apologised for any viewer inadvertently entertained.

Nice one.  Spot on.

Mmmatt wrote (see)

Have any of you watched the Tour De France?

8 guys that won't overtake their leader (except when it'll save him some effort) - it's the biggest spectator event on the planet. Recommended.

Cycling is totally different from F1.   The tactical and aerodynamic advantages of teamwork make an insurmountable difference in cycling - and it is part of the spectator spectacle. The thing I'd change is to give out team medals in cycling, istead of (or as well as) individual medals.

In F1, on-track team work has very little effect.  Any driver can win without help from a team-mate... and that teamwork is not part of the spectator spectacle.   Team orders were banned in 2002... because it makes a mockery of the sport.  The decision was lifted in 2011, not because it was wrong to ban it, but because they couldn't enforce it.

WiB
25/03/2013 at 14:34

F1 is a joke when they pull stunts like at the weekend. I am glad is back fired on them. Thankfully it has not really made its way into bike racing yet, well, not anything beyond the occasional going easy on their championship leading team mate at the last race of the year.

Even when team orders were banned, they found ways around it. For example, pull the other car in for a pit stop needlessly.

WiB
25/03/2013 at 16:49

Cycling is a very subtle and tactical sport, you can tell this because the really average cyclist dumbly raced off really quickly and were sat around looking stupid and feeling sheepish with their medals hung around their necks whilst the decent teams were still out on the course arguing over who should try a little bit cos it won't be us.

With my untrained eye these subtlties passed me by and it just looked like the Brits cocked it up wholesale, their argument that if they tried to catch them up other teams might chase them down was genius, much better to stay in the peloton and not let that happen. For a cycling team that claims to focus on the tiny percentages they didn't seem to have much in the way of contingency planning.

F1 - A car overtakes another car and headlines spin around the globe, says it all. Still Hamilton pitting at Maclaren amused me greatly. 

cougie    pirate
25/03/2013 at 17:02
So you think that you understand cycling better than Team GB oirisheyes ?
It's so easy to say that they got it wrong without offering the correct tactics.

It's a lot easier to make a team or person lose than it is to win.

Vino isn't exactly an average cyclist. He's won multiple stages and big races.
GB can't mark everyone. If they tried theyd be worn out half way through the race.
25/03/2013 at 17:14
I think tactics is part of why cycling is such a great sport. F1 on the other hand is something else. Far too much is decided by events outside of the skills of the driver. I love cycling and can watch the Tour for hours. F1 I can't watch for more than 5 minutes.
WiB
25/03/2013 at 17:29
As a big motorsport fan I don't want to agree but certainly in terms of F1 that us exactly right.
WiB
26/03/2013 at 06:56
Run Wales wrote (see)

In F1, on-track team work has very little effect.  Any driver can win without help from a team-mate... and that teamwork is not part of the spectator spectacle.


I think that's only partly true. reliability is the xtra (rather boring!) element in F1. If a driver (e.g. Webber) is leading comfortably he can save the car and increase his finishing chances - a compliant teammate can help a lot here.

Also, in motorsport overtaking is often problematic - see the RedBull coming together in (IIRC) Turkey2010. No team wants that - far better to have a somewhat boring 1-2 and risk some public derision.

26/03/2013 at 16:45

Team orders should have no place in F1. If a driver is capable of overtaking, then he should go for it.

26/03/2013 at 19:22
So when is a team not a team?

We'd love you to add a comment! Please login or take half a minute to register as a free member
21 to 29 of 29 messages
Previously bookmarked threads are now visible in "Followed Threads". You can also manage notifications on these threads from the "Forum Settings" section of your profile settings page to prevent being sent an email when a reply is made.
Forum Jump  

RW competitions

RW Forums