Poppies.

1 to 20 of 284 messages
06/11/2013 at 17:09

It's shocking how few people seem to be wearing a poppy this year compared to previous years. The money goes to looking after British servicemen and women who have been injured fighting in various conflicts around the world, and also to help the families who have lost loved ones in action.

Surely it's not too much to expect people to buy a poppy and wear it. Wear your poppy with pride.

06/11/2013 at 17:12

+1

I noticed that, its not difficult to pop some money in a box, and do something for the people who have done a lot for us.

cougie    pirate
06/11/2013 at 17:14
I've got a poppy - but its always on the other coat. I'm sorry.
06/11/2013 at 17:17

Maybe there should be some sort of anti-war poppy that people can wear. I will never wear a poppy but respect that people were forced to serve in two world wars and tragically lost their lives. I feel sad that people lost their lives in recent conflicts but they chose to go. 

06/11/2013 at 17:20

Poppies don't actually celebrate war. They commemorate those that made the ultimate sacrifice.

06/11/2013 at 17:20

Totally agree Rickster, what's a couple of quid, they last years if you look after them too, had mine since 1998.

06/11/2013 at 17:25

I fall short of agreeing with him because I think if there was a stronger anti war message with the poppy day commemoration I think people would be more willing to wear one. 

06/11/2013 at 17:26

Remembrance day is the 11th November.  That's in five days.  I will buy one and wear it closer to the time, but I will not be guilt tripped into wandering around with one for what seems like an ever increasing amount of time beforehand.

06/11/2013 at 17:35

You haven't seen me wear one cos I haven't got one yet, but I will because I think it's a good cause.  It does seem to be pretty close to the top of the guilt-trip list though.  Why isn't EVERYONE giving some of their money on a yearly basis to every cancer / homeless / old people / poor people / sick people / sick animals / starving children / destitute badger charity? And if they're not, why aren't we having a go about it?

seren nos    pirate
06/11/2013 at 17:38

i put money in the box and I remember those who died in my prayers and attend the rememberance service...

I do not wear a poppy.....I do not wear little badges for every charity i support.......just so i can be seen to say....aren't I brilliant i put some spare change in the pot...or i kept mine from last year and its still good....

or you can get a bigger more expensive poppy to show everyone how much better you are than them......

but of those who wear the poppies for weeks or days....apart from giving a few pennies to the charity what do you do.....do you give up a day to volunteer colllection........or a day volunteering in a hospital that helps those who were hurt........

maybe you have volunteered to be trained as  a councellor to help those who are sufferring......or have you slept rough in the streets trying to find those who need help

or maybe you just wear your poppy to be smug without actually having to do much to help the people affected......

06/11/2013 at 17:44

I happened to be in blackpool last year for remembrance sunday. i was taken aback by how widely acknowledged the day was. much more than is my experience in either dundee or glasgow. the streets were lined with people. I had lost my poppy (of course) but i  bought another.

I do wear a poppy (when it has not fallen off) but I do not feel the need to comment on whether other people do or do not wear one.

as seren pointed out, people make their contribution in different ways.

06/11/2013 at 17:57

I'm with seren, I put some money in each year but don't take a poppy.

06/11/2013 at 18:06

Rather than writing out a long diatribe, basically its easier to say 'See Sussex Runners response for what I think as well'

 

06/11/2013 at 19:06

Mine fell off too. May get another but as I donate on a monthly basis I'm not too bothered. I'm also in with those who don't feel the need to wear a token for all the charities I support.

06/11/2013 at 19:39

I have my poppy, which I will probably lose and end up buying a new one before Parade on Sunday (same happens every year)

 

 

06/11/2013 at 19:48

I always put money in the pot but never take a poppy anymore.  I used to, but they inevitably got lost within the first hour and ended up littering somewhere.

Surely the important thing is what goes on inside your head rather than whether you take a piece of commercial plastic or not

06/11/2013 at 20:18
Sussex Runner NLR wrote (see)

I fall short of agreeing with him because I think if there was a stronger anti war message with the poppy day commemoration I think people would be more willing to wear one. 

The Peace Pledge Union actually sell white poppies because of their opinion that the red poppy is tied to military culture. White poppies also used to be worn by the Shot at Dawn campaigners until those British soldiers executed during WW1 were pardoned in 2006.

So there is an alternative.

06/11/2013 at 20:39

I buy a poppy each year, if it falls off or I wear another coat I do not worry too much. I have a poppy as a reminder for the fallen in war and also wear an ordinary brooch on my clothes as my great grandmother died on the 11th of November 1918, a victim of the Spanish flu epidemic.

06/11/2013 at 20:58

I see just as many poppies around as I usually see at this time of year, certainly the majority of people I see day to day are wearing one.

I didn't know about the shot at dawn campaign using the white poppy, but outside of that I  never understood the white poppy thing,  wearing a red poppy has only ever been about remembrance. 

06/11/2013 at 21:13

Well it's a fine line for the Royal British Legion to tread.

It seems to me that young people are the ones who don't wear poppies because they don't see the relevance. They won't have known many people, if any, that remember the Second World War, let alone the First.

If the RBL wants to keep its donations up then it needs those younger people to buy into the idea of remembrance - in doing so it does run the risk of promoting the idea that war is inevitable, perpetual and perhaps even necessary.

Recent conflicts in which British service personnel have died have also been controversial - which doesn't help.

Edited: 06/11/2013 at 21:16
1 to 20 of 284 messages
Previously bookmarked threads are now visible in "Followed Threads". You can also manage notifications on these threads from the "Forum Settings" section of your profile settings page to prevent being sent an email when a reply is made.
Forum Jump  

RW Forums