( Decides to stir it all up again)
AS I posted on the last page... it all depends on what tehaward represents and why it is made. I think all accept it has nothing to do with personality.
So, is it about the sporting hero/legend that stands out over the year? Is it about being the best in your field? Is it about personifying dedication to the art? Is it about being a successful flash in the pan, or about longevity?
I think the problem is that no-one, not least the BBC knows. Where does Zara Phillips fit in to any of that? Gioggs? Well he's a great player who has outlasted the majority of others... so on the longevity route / good role model route he qualifies. I guess the majority of those taking an interest in the thread are indicating that an award is apt, just not this one.?
( opens box, puts wooden spoon away)