George: your optimum choice will depend on your foot shape as well as trail type, because some of the shoes are narrower, some wider.
VivoBarefoot Neo Trail took me through NDW50 both on the day (quite dry) and on very wet & muddy recce days. I am however thinking about getting a pair of those new Inov8 Trailroc 235s ready for Lakeland 50 next year, assuming they fit my feet.