Motion control shoes

Not all overpronators are big guys

10 messages
16/11/2002 at 00:53
Anyone out there who severely overpronates but isn't a "big guy"?

Time for me to change my shoes. Currently using Nike Air Durhams, but getting warning signs in the shins and knees.

Any recommendations, so I know what models to ask to try out? Reason I'm asking mid-weight runners is that most motion-control shoes seem designed for blokes a lot heavier than my 10 and a half stone. Soft ride preferred, more like marshmallow the better.

Ta in advance.
16/11/2002 at 07:59
Do you honestly expect anybody to admit to not being a "Big Guy"?
16/11/2002 at 14:55
Depends what you mean by "big guy". I'm 5'10" and weigh just 10 and a half stone, but then I do take size 11 shoes... :-)
18/11/2002 at 16:28
Hi Muttley

I'm a gal that is somewhere between 9.5 and 10 stone (only 5ft 4in!). I'm currently wearing Brooks Ariel (lady version of Beast). They are quite rigid and took a bit of wearing in, so don't think they would suit you if you want a more flexible shoe. Have you tried Saucony Grid Stabil? I believe they are motion control shoes and want to give them a try the next time I change my shoes.

I did try Asics Kayano a year ago but they caused me all sorts of calf and black toe nail problems (I even tried going up half a size to see if that would help!).

Sorry not to be much help.

Creamcake
18/11/2002 at 16:30
Also believe Saucony do a Grid Courageous (just having a look through a Saucony booklet I grabbed whilst at the running shop last!).

Should have put that on my last message but looked through booklet as an afterthought - sorry!

Would the Asics 2070 have enough support - I know they are just classed as a stability shoe but as you're not a big guy...

Just a few thoughts for the melting pot (hubble, bubble, toil and trouble...)

Creamcake (CC)
18/11/2002 at 16:39
Hi Muttley
Like Creamcake I have a pair of Brooks Ariel. But my favourite motion control shoes are the Asics Koji & have found that these to be excellent, I think Total Fitness Nottingham have them on their site if you need more info on them
Cheers
Roisin
18/11/2002 at 17:13
The Nike Kantara is a strong support shoe but not designed simply for "big-guys"?I wear them and I'm only 10 stone?Might be worth a try
19/11/2002 at 09:47
Hi Mutley, I don't concider myself a big guy (some might though), I' 5'6" and 12st 3lbs. I overpronate and wear orthosis and I am currently running in a pair of Mizuno Wave Legends which a re a motion control shoe. I had previously used Mizuno Wave Conviction (stability). The Waves are fairly light, reasonably flexible and took no breaking in at all. The guy at Runner's Need said that it is a myth that shoes like these and the Beast are only for heavy runners. It boils down to what works for you.
19/11/2002 at 10:59
Much appreciation to all for replying.

I've tried the Beast and (?Gel MC) in the past, and found them hard underfoot - I got the impression the cushioning and shock-absorption were designed for a greater weight than mine.

I switched to the Nike Durhams after being told to reduce impact. These feel very soft underfoot, so I might go one further and look at the Kantara as well.

Cheers again, I'll try the models you suggest.
19/11/2002 at 21:05
Hi,

You should also look at the Saucony Omni 3 Ultimate. I'm running in it now and it's a great shoe for severe overpronators, but in a 12oz package. It will give you more support than the 2070. Happy running. DL.

We'd love you to add a comment! Please login or take half a minute to register as a free member
10 messages
Previously bookmarked threads are now visible in "Followed Threads". You can also manage notifications on these threads from the "Forum Settings" section of your profile settings page to prevent being sent an email when a reply is made.
Forum Jump  

RW Forums