Had the Garmin soft strap for about a year. I got the occasional spike at the start of a run, but everything then settled down. Over the course of the year the strap became more unreliable, with spikes throughout runs. I recently bought the polar soft strap for ??10, and with the Garmin sensor attached its been perfect. I'm not too impressed that Garmin expect you to replace the strap and sensor at a cost of ??45
I also have the Garmin hard strap that I use for rowing. I find it really reliable, although not quite as comfortable for running. Its important with the soft straps to wash them after each use otherwise it seems to shorten their life.
Edited: 16/02/2013 at 03:55