Its worth bearing in mind that absolutely anyone can call themselves a nutritionist and start giving out advice.
As a recently diagnosed coeliac (I'm 50) I've had problems with dairy products, but having read the blurb from the coeliac bods, I see that they may be due to my inability to process gluten. Once I've stabilised following removal of gluten from my diet, I may be able to return to eating dairy.
If you have problems with wheat, that may explain the dairy, but as others have said, the only real way to test is either via blood test (which you get for coeliac) or exclusion diet. If you follow the later, providing it is conducted under proper and professional guidelines, it will enable you to identify and eliminate the "culprits".
If you really are determined to remove wheat, you need to check everything - Oxo cubes for eg contain wheat - otherwise you may find yourself eating it inadvertently, so prolonging your symptoms (whatever they may be).
However, by removing so much from your diet, you could end up with a nutritional imbalance, which won't help matters at all. I'm guessing that this is a self-referral rather than via your GP? If you have serious concerns about your health, then try your GP first, he/she may be able to either give you tests or refer you to nutrionist on the NHS.
CJBA wrote (see)
CJBA - coeliac disease can cause a secondary lactase deficiency - hence the problems with dairy. This is reversible, as your small intestine recovers now you're on a gluten free diet.
Have you tried Genius gluten free bread? It's not available on prescription, but is the nicest GF bread that I've found.
gosh didn't think i'd have so many responses!
Lardarse-im afraid i can't eat whatever i feel like as i get very ill, you must feel very lucky.
Went to so many doctors the past 5 years and none of them were helpful. They just keep saying ibs, which yes i do suffer from but they couldnt help me as to what was aggrevating the ibs. I've had a few tests done so coeliac is ruled out but they said they wouldnt test my intolerances on the nhs (big surprise) so she gave me 3 names i should go see and my women was 1 of them.
I completely agree it probably is a load of rubbish but im inclined to beleive her as she atleastgave me some answer''s rather than nothing!!
Yes, thanks for that Sarah, I've been on a g-f diet since June, so after 50yrs of eating the wrong stuff, it's going to take a while for my gut to settle, but I'm confident that it will.
I try a bit of dairy from time to time, to see how it's going. No 1 Child has similar problems, but we seem OK with lactose-free cheese and yoghurts, although I have to say that now that I've got used to eating soya yoghurts, I think I prefer them to the "real thing".
And yes, we've tried genius - the closest to real bread. I've changed my breadmaker to the g-f version and made some bread - not brilliant, but just have to get used to it!
My favourite lunchtime special used to be cheese and marmite on toast not any more
sarah the bookworm wrote (see)
Go and see a dietitian!Not that I'm biased at all...
Go and see a dietitian!
Not that I'm biased at all...
Correct. Anyone can claim to be a nutritionist. It's about as scientific as homeopathy. Before you know it Gillian McKeith is sifting through your poo!
Dietitians are qualified health professionals. I'd rather show my poo to them.
Michael Hughes 10 wrote (see)
Correct. Anyone can claim to be a nutritionist. It's about as scientific as homeopathy. Before you know it Gillian McKeith is sifting through your poo!Dietitians are qualified health professionals. I'd rather show my poo to them.
The Hoose-Goer wrote (see)
anybody can see my poo if they follow me on a run
Sarah - I know you say you'd rather believe her because she's at least given you some answers, but unless those answers are the right ones, you won't benefit. If you're willing to pay, you can find freelance dietitians - at least you know that the person you see is properly trained and is regulated. If you are intent on following this nutritionist's advice, at the very least only cut out one food at a time to see if there is any improvement in your symptoms. I'd also add that if you do have IBS, there is a strong psychological element to it - stress hormones can play havoc with your bowels. Eliminating particular foods won't make the slightest difference to your symptoms unless the source of the stress is dealt with. That's assuming of course that there is a stress element to your case - there might not be
Also, if you have been diagnosed with IBS, your GP should have referred you to a dietitian. Not to identify intolerances (if you ask for a referral on that basis the GP is likely to refuse) but to help you to formulate a diet and meal pattern that alleviates your symptoms. Once you've got your appointment you can discuss whatever issues are of concern to you So go back to the GP!
i have a special bush called George
I wont ask if you have a bush and what you call it, being the gentleman I am
Hoosie - behave yourself
You won't be allowed back on the nifties thread if you're not careful
Visit the official Runner's World page
Follow Runner's World on Twitter
Other Natmag-Rodale Sites
Run For Charity
About Runner's World
Runner's World is a publication of Hearst Magazines UK which is the trading name of The National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.
Website powered by: Immediate Media Company Ltd. | © Runner's World 2002-2013 |