RW Forum Six - Sub 3:30

Minni v Dubai Dave

361 to 380 of 39,668 messages
27/01/2011 at 09:00

Thanks for the excellent advice Moraghan and DD.

Minni – Others may disagree but I think adding a bit of speed work earlier in your scheduled would be a good idea and the reason I recommended the 800m x 10 earlier. You can of course do less reps or change the distance as long as there is some progression. The P&D Advanced Marathon book is as close to a running bible as you might get but in my point of view there is one weakness. It doesn’t take into consideration the individual runner’s strength and weaknesses. No cookie cutter schedule can.

I have little doubt that if you follow the P&D schedule to the letter you will achieve your goal time. However, if you adjust the schedule slightly taking into consideration your own strength and weaknesses you are likely to find your goal easier to achieve. This is what I did to change myself from a sub 3:30 marathon runner to a sub 3:15 marathon runner inside 5 months.

If you believe that speed is your weakness then it should be something that you work on a little bit more. If you can increase your 10k pace by 10 seconds during the campaign then it should have a knock on effect for you marathon pace come race day.

I’d be interested to read DD and Moraghan’s opinions on this.

Dubai Dave    pirate
27/01/2011 at 11:30

BB: I'm with you, speedwork IMO is absolutely essential to get marathon times down its a staple of my weekly running, it was only when it went into my weekly schedule that my times started to improve. As I have already said Minni clearly needs to learn to train faster than she presently is so that she can race at quicker paces up to 1/2M.

In my experience with running a club for several years most runners shy away from intervals, if you can persaude a runner to come along a couple of times and they begin to realise a) they can do this and b) they start to see progression the job is done and speed work will stay in their schedules at least part of the year. It doesn't matter if you are a half decent runner or a complete beginner speedwork will make you quicker.

Of course the risk with speed work is always injury but this can be minimized by a) adequate warm ups b) Slowly increasing the number of reps, distance, pace, decreasing the recoveries etc.

27/01/2011 at 11:32

Badbark - I'm not wholly convinced Minni has a "speed problem" per se.  Her best half time is quick enough to comfortably go under 3:30. 

There is something clearly wrong with Minni's 10k time.  Rounding down to nearest whole minute her best 10k time is 7:23 pace but her best HM pace is 7:20!  That can't be explained in terms of fitness and is more likely an issue of circumstance.

Assuming that speed were a problem marathon training is the wrong time to address it in my opinion.  There are two factors to a good marathon:  your short distance "speed" and your ability to convert it.  I think if you were to try and work on both during marathon training it would be a mistake.  Particularly as speed-challenged runners often struggle (during them and recovering from them) with classic speed sessions. Your speed will often improve as a result of marathon focused sessions but that is a very different thing from actually trying to improve speed by changing your sessions during marathon training.

For this reason most runners would be far better training for one marathon a year with the other 6 months focusing on a shorter distance.

Dubai Dave    pirate
27/01/2011 at 11:39
Moraghan wrote (see)

For this reason most runners would be far better training for one marathon a year with the other 6 months focusing on a shorter distance.

Fair point, has been one of my biggest failings in the past. Though would change that to one serious or raced  marathon a year ( I ran Athens for fun in October but didn't put much into it).

27/01/2011 at 14:02

Without a doubt there is a problem with my 10k time and I think a lot of it has to do with confidence.  Before a 10k I am anxious about speed, worried about injury and just basically stressed.  I'm uptight on the start line and this stays with me throughout.  Whereas before a marathon I am totally relaxed.  I always sleep well the night before, one the start line I am looking forward to the run ahead, and I feel confident and relaxed. 

When I ran Newcastle in November I counted 11 ladies in front of me on the first lap. I didn't let their faster pace worry me because I was confident I would pass some of them later on.  I ended up finishing in 6th position with a race finish.  There was only 6 seconds between me and the lady who came 3rd.

However, I cannot seem to transfer this confidence to the shorter distance. 

27/01/2011 at 19:39

Interesting debates on speed work etc.

The guest speakers at last night's marathon training session were Liz Yelling and her husband, absolutely inspirational!  They talked about a variety of training methods, pitched at all abilities, however in relation to discussion on here - she did recommend (depending on experience) 1 or 2 speed sessions a week - mixing it up with LT and intervals.  Her other key point was running at marathon pace - incorporating that into long runs so that you are absolutely comfortable and know how it feels to run at that specific pace.  So all the advice appearing on here is in line with her recommendations!

I'm incredibly tired today, so going to grab an early night and have switched tonight's medium long run to tomorrow morning.

27/01/2011 at 22:24

Kiwi -  tell us more!  Sounds like you had a great night?   Tell us more.....

kiwirunner10 wrote (see)

  Her other key point was running at marathon pace - incorporating that into long runs so that you are absolutely comfortable and know how it feels to run at that specific pace.

I'm hearing that more and more these days

 I found this forum back in 2003/04 when I did my first marathon and I have learnt almost everything I know from it.  But, its amazing how much more I'm learning this year.  Maybe because I'm reading with new eyes as I try to get this goal.  Thank you to all those who are offering views, experience, and knowledge.

I did 5 miles tonight and feel more or less back to normal. General Aerobic with some strides and 3 x 30 second hill reps; similar to the session I would have done on Tuesday as part of the 10 mile.  I'm hopeful I will be ok for the lactate threshold tomorrow (5 + 5).  

I might have to double up for my mid run for the next couple of weeks.  Short staffed and struggling to get the time.  I'm thinking that perhaps I could add 2 or 3  800m  reps into either the morning or evening run as an introduction to them, and also to make one session slightly harder than the other? 

28/01/2011 at 07:15

Minni, you might to dip into the 2011 Marathon Thread. There's some great advice and knowledgeable folk on there
Dubai Dave    pirate
28/01/2011 at 08:32


Minni any introduction into speed work is going to help you, likewise being able to hit marathon pace with your eyes shut is just so important. As you get used to ruuning at different paces you will find that you are able accurately feel 5K/10K/ 1/2M/ Marathon pace without reference to a garmin / watch. I have no idea how the human brain is capable of doing that but it does, I can hit a pace without ever connciously thinking about it and am always amazed when studying my garmin afterwards shows pretty much the pace I was planning on.

My right calf is still buggered from last weeks marathon as a quick fitness test showed me last night so thank god for my bike, did 2 hours today probably 4 or 5 tomorrow. Its good job I like cycling!

28/01/2011 at 12:07
Morning folks - 18 miles in the bag this morning done and dusted before a busy weekend. Much better than last week, although I did them on the treadmill at 11.4kph and upped it to 12kph for the last 5k. We've had a few sitings of wierdos flashig at women running round here on the lanes so its frightened me a bit - and one of my friends was flashed at again this morning while she was out running. Horrible hey.
28/01/2011 at 17:05
deleted... double post.
Edited: 28/01/2011 at 17:06
28/01/2011 at 17:05

I used to get sore calfs Dave, and it was always great to get one the  bike when they were playing up.  I hope its nothing serious? 

AA You mad woman!  18 on the treadmill... hat off to you again.  That's not nice having a flasher around you.  I really don't think men know how vulnerable women feel when they're out running on their own.  The chaps in my club laugh at me!  I'll go out in the hills all day myself but on the road I hate going more than a couple of miles on my own! 

 10 miles LT run in the bag.   I did the same route as last week and took the first 5 easy (this was also the hilliest bit) then pushed the other half.  The strap on my garmin snapped as I was putting it on so I had to grab my old navman, which gives me total time, distance and pace but not mile for mile.  The average pace was 8.20 and, although I'm not as good at telling my pace as you Dave, I know I was working really hard in the second half  ...probably close to my pace last weekend... I couldn't have held a conversation and was hurting.  It felt harder than the same last week but I'm pleased with the pace.  

My hamstrings are still hurting and I feel like something in my hips needs to click.  Might visit the physio...

Its my running club Christmas party and awards night tomorrow night.  As Chairman, its my job to get it all together.  Right now I am making 20 odd awards (we're a low budget club....!) and doing times for a blind handicap I've arranged for the afternoon.  There are a few runners doing it who haven't been brave enough to come along to the club yet, so I'm looking forward to encouraging them. 

Long run for me on Sunday.  Good luck with long runs everyone else. 

Edited: 28/01/2011 at 17:06
28/01/2011 at 20:55
Minni - do you have to run blindfolded at your club handicap? Lol
Dubai Dave    pirate
29/01/2011 at 07:21


Minni, well done with your LT run and good luck with the club party. I was club chairman for two years up to 31.12.10, its tough getting everything organised and keeping everyone happy.

You are probably right that most men (me included) don't realise how vunerable women feel running on their own.

My calf will be OK I ended up trotting 3K yesterday around the local bike track yesterday behind my litlle one who I thought would have trouble riding his bike without stablisers but who went off like a rocket with dad in pursuit! No reaction by calf at all and then a extended set of sprints while playing tag passed without incident. Just back from 4.5 hours on the bike, fantastic!

30/01/2011 at 17:19

Hi all,

Hope everyone has had successful long runs this weekend.  I struggled through 18 miles yesterday am, had planned to do a progressive run but only got to 8:45 m/m in the last 8 miles, no where near 8 m/m, came home feeling like a bit of a failure!  But trying not to get too stressed out at this stage about hitting marathon pace at the end of long runs - I've never incorporated marathon pace at the end of long runs before but am constantly being told via different sources that this is one of the keys to improving marathon times. 

Was nearly going to flag this morning's cross country league race, but went along and came away feeling more positive, not really ran much cross country before, ended up 20th lady in the first league race back at the start of December, 13th lady today on a very hilly course.  So even though I am struggling with pace in training sessions, I definately am noticing the difference in races.....

Mini - Liz Yelling and her husband pitched their speech at all abilities, so it wasn't too 'technical'.  She did say if you are an experienced runner you would benefit from including one LT and one interval speed session each week, she too emphasised how important it was to get to know how your marathon pace feels, in steady mid week runs and to include race pace in the second half of your long runs every second week.  We were given a little training diary, pitched at intermediate runners, which includes a mixture of LT and Interval training in a week or a medium long run mid week at your marathon pace.  Like D.D she said you need to know how your marathon pace feels without looking at a watch.... She also recommended to have a couple of tune up races to gauge how your training is going, to that affect I have entered a 10 mile race end of Feb, and a half March 20th.

That's the main bits, sorry I'm not very good at retaining and passing on information.  She was amazing though - her marathon p.b is 2:28!!  They had a slide show, at one point a photo of her 'sprinting' at mile 23 came up, I was thinking, oh to look that good at mile 23!!

30/01/2011 at 19:35

That sounds like a great night Kiwi.  Liz Yelling coached Matchstick Man last year in the SuperSix and she was brilliant on the forum.  She offered loads of advice to everyone.

I wouldn't worry too much about your 18 miler -  18 miles is 18 miles, and you had a great xcountry today so you still had plenty left. 

I had an odd week last week.  I played down just how yuk I was feeling and I was worried that I'd peaked and it was going to be all downhill.  My hamstring is hurting a bit on the faster runs but not enough to cause a problem as such.  I've made an appointment with the physio tomorrow night to have ti checked out.  Strangely, it didn't bother me much today when I was running a slower pace.

I got the club handicap out the way yesterday (I was organising so didn't do it) and the club party last night.  I kept to 3 glasses of wine otherwise I might have had to skip my run today.  I decided to go off road but didn't chose as hilly as route as the last one, but it would still be classed as hilly by most standards.  I didn't worry about the pace and it was really nice just to be able to relax and enjoy the run.  And I felt much better!  18 miles done with an average pace of 9.50.  The last three miles were 8.12; 8.00; 7.15.

30/01/2011 at 21:00

Minni - cracking last three miles! Well done. 

KR  - I had one of those 18 mile runs last week, I think its really common. ANd like you say you're improving in races. We've still got a long way to go in our training.

Recovery week for me now  Couple of speed sessions, a not-so-long long run and some extra rest days

Dubai Dave    pirate
31/01/2011 at 04:32

Kiwi: 18 miles is exactly that 18 miles in the bank, so you couldn't hit 8 min/miles at the end, well that takes practice and your way ahead of most marathon runners now because you realise that it is important to be able to run at MP when tired.

Liz Yelling is a bit of a hero of mine, her achievements have always been over shadowed by Paula but she has competed in two Olympics and been the first British finisher in both, plus a commonwealth bronze. Yet I doubt if many of the British public are even aware she exists.

Minni: Top running particularly on the back of a week when you didn't feel so good.

AA: Very true there is a very long way to go, something I have to keep telling myself with regard to my IM training.

Have fun out there.

31/01/2011 at 11:28

Tried 6 miles MP today. Managed 7;55, 7:58, 7:59, 7:46, 7:42 and 7:43. Absolutley bloody freezing - was breathing fire the whole way  Finished with the "absolutely no way could I do this for 26.2 miles in 10 weeks time" feeling. But hey ho! 10 weeks is a long time!

31/01/2011 at 12:16
Well done AA - like you say, 10 weeks is a long time
361 to 380 of 39,668 messages
Previously bookmarked threads are now visible in "Followed Threads". You can also manage notifications on these threads from the "Forum Settings" section of your profile settings page to prevent being sent an email when a reply is made.
Forum Jump  

RW competitions

RW Forums