Well done on making the shortlist KR - I think the fact that you're the sole male out of the three should work in your favour
Lot's of interesting debate on MP and P&D.
As I'm flicking through a typical P&D schedule, and having previously taken a "lace up the daps and run" approach to training, why don't they write training programmes in the same language, so I'm assuming in P&D terms "general aerobic" is equivalent of "steady state" as referred to by Moraghan.
But there seems to be a lack of MP mentioned in P&D, in the 55-70 (18wk) schedule MP is only practised in week 9 and week 13 in a LSR, then a 2m dress rehearsal during the final taper week. (SBD as resident P&D guru help me out here). Is P&D light on this? Would you advocate ramping up MP practise for the LSRs??
Perhaps I need to resign as thread "P&D guru"
All I can say in my defence is that, having never trained for a marathon before and being devoid of any natural speed, I used the P&D training programme to nail 3:05 and 2:59 in successive marathons in 2010. Whilst you need to tailor a training programme to your strengths and weaknesses, my approach was to follow P&D to the letter to see what worked and what didn't work. So far I haven't found much that didn't work
I interpreted General Aerobic as "a bit faster than recovery pace" but essentially time on feet. I ran these no faster than the recommended MP+15% but capped the effort according to HR as well (75% WHR).
Is P&D light on MP? I think there are 4 MP in LSR sessions with the last 8, 10, 12, 14 miles at MP. If I've done these as training runs I've usually struggled to hit MP but if I've run them as part of a race I've usually gone faster than MP. For this campaign, I've got 5K, 9mile and HM races lined up for each of these sessions. I'll probably aim to do the first 2 at goal MP and the latter 2 at slightly faster than MP.
I always ran the LSRs and MLRs using the 20%/10% progressive approach. That said, whilst at the beginning of the schedule the faster last 8 miles was at MP+10%, as the campaign progressed this pace increased (I would aim to run this at just below marathon pace HR) and reached MP+2% just before the taper. So I may have been guilty of running a lot more MP miles than I thought