Cross training - swimming

1 to 20 of 21 messages
20/02/2003 at 22:23
I used one training session this week to swim instead of run. How do I calculate the 'equivalent' mileage?
20/02/2003 at 22:54
Id like the answer to this too
20/02/2003 at 23:16
I once read an article in running mag. that quantified the different types of exercise by quoting the amount of calories used per hour of running,cycling,swimming and so forth.Not really much help, but, it may be a start in answering your question.
21/02/2003 at 00:03
Helen, just looked this up in Bob Glovers book today as my training log also demands I put something in! He said 1 mile swim is equal to about 4-5 mile run. Obviously the training effect also depends on how hard you're working.
Swimming also has other benefits of course, in my case the only time I ever do anything resembling upper body work, relaxing, stimulates blood flow to sore/tired muscles, cooling etc.
WildWill    pirate
21/02/2003 at 00:19
A good swimmer will do 3k in the time a good runner does 10k

Hope that helps
21/02/2003 at 07:58
Found this after I posted the question:

http://www.coolrunning.com/engine/2/115.shtml

WW - htta is a 'good' swimmer. I managed 2.33k in my 10k running time last night, but wasn't sure if the CV benefit was the same as my heart rate would have been a bit lower.
21/02/2003 at 08:49
Do you really need to compare them?

If i swim i compare that with my other swimtraining and if i run i do the same with my runninglogs.

21/02/2003 at 13:48
Depends on the type of swimming you do as well - I can do a mile of breast stroke in my 10k time (ish) with little effort, but as for front crawl ... usually drowning and collapsing in a heap after 100 metres.

I log my swimming (and everything else I do) in my running log, but only as a record - I don't calculate equivalent mileage as I don't think that it is really possible to compare two activities.
Trogs    pirate
21/02/2003 at 22:48
Onrunning.com used to have Q&A facility and I once asked this question for swimming and biking there. Their answer was 1 mile swim = 4 miles run and 4 miles bike = 1 mile run.

Not sure how you compare training effort and effect though.
22/02/2003 at 11:06
I use swimming for what it is swimming, knowing that it's helping my breathing technique and upper body strength along with easing any muscle stiffness. There is no need to use it as an 'equivlent' to running. All I need to know is that it complements my running and after even 30 mins of continuous swimming front crawl I've had a good workout.
22/02/2003 at 16:27
Oh this is interesting since I now have to swim owing to injury.
23/02/2003 at 22:16
I tend to base swim sessions on hear rate and do reps with measured rests as in a running speed session. So rather than focusing on the distance covered, I'm more bothered about the intensity of the workout and the training effects, e.g. an endurance session/speed session/easy, etc.
WildWill    pirate
23/02/2003 at 22:33
Freakette

That is actually how i do my swim traing - each session has a purpose - so train to fulfill that purpose
WildWill    pirate
23/02/2003 at 22:34
In the summer i like to go and wim in the sea - here i spend about 60-90mins just having fun in the water :o)
23/02/2003 at 22:38
;) I swam in the sea once and got stung by a jellyfish so never dared again...though I was on holiday somewhere nice and warm at the time! Where do you swim? There's nowt quite like a paddle in the sea to get you going - it's soooooo much better than the pool!
WildWill    pirate
23/02/2003 at 22:44
A place called Cullar Coats on the north east cost - nice bay protected by 2 large piers - it comes in as good practice for open water races
23/02/2003 at 22:50
Hmmmm, might give it a go this summer...
WildWill    pirate
23/02/2003 at 22:51
Wet suits help
23/02/2003 at 23:02
Aaaahhh - that could be useful; cheers!
24/02/2003 at 14:28
My physio is a very experienced long distance swimmer having swum the Channel and trained last year to swim the Thames.He told me that a pool swim is equivalent to 4 times the running distance and a sea swim is approx.6 times depending on the currents etc. He also stated that swimming training is far more beneficial to runners than most people realise, but that running does not have the same effect on swimming!!
1 to 20 of 21 messages
Previously bookmarked threads are now visible in "Followed Threads". You can also manage notifications on these threads from the "Forum Settings" section of your profile settings page to prevent being sent an email when a reply is made.
Forum Jump  

RW competitions

RW Forums