In short: a day to remember, but for the wrong reasons. In full: this was my 50th marathon and my 5th edinburgh marathon. having seen how the route has changed so much and how the number of entrants has increased it appears to me the race has not improved by this. to run out of water is extremely poor and also dangerous in such conditions, and again as in 2008 getting from the finish line through the crowds and back to the city via the buses really is very difficult. the route might be fast for the vast minority of elite runners but is this really the major factor for the masses, probably not. if the race continues to finish so far out the city I think my days visiting edinburgh are over which saddens me really. improvements/changes needed with immediate effect and if necessary limit the number of entrants because clearly the organisers cannot cope. not good. Date of review: June 2, 2009
In short: nightmare at the end !!! In full: the route was tougher than I expected and was not as flat as I thought it would be. the drinks stations were well stocked and marshalls/volunteers were very supportive. the latter stages of the race were rather busier with traffic coming too close for my liking at times. also, not keen on having to run round dismounted cyclists pushing their bikes up the hills when I am feeling tired and exhausted. sadly, will remember this day for the chaos in leaving the venue. It took us over ninety minutes to exit the field and this was an awful and frustrating experience. Also, to run out of medals is not good at all. To close, massive respect and congratulations to the 10 in 10 runners. Truly awesome achievement, I take my hat off to you all. Date of review: May 18, 2009
In short: tough day at the office !! In full: the organisation from the start , during and at the finish was extremely good and smooth. it is as mentioned a hilly course in places and thankfully it did cloud over otherwise it would have been too hot. personally, I found the course very repetitive and not as scenic as others describe it. the plastic cups were not ideal, I would prefer bottles on such a warm day. have done quite a few marathons now and I would not rate this in my top 5. congratulations and thanks to ALL the volunteers and marshalls, job well done.
In short: p.b. broke 1 30 In full: the scenery is not the best in the world but the organisation was top drawer and the goody bag excellent making this race well worth the trip from dingle land. broke my pb by almost 3 minutes and to break 1 30 was a target I never thought I would actually achieve. arguably my best running day ever and thanks to all the organisers. to close, separate changing areas for male and female runners would be a good idea.
In short: mud mud and more mud In full: done 40 marathons and never ever ran in conditions like this ! not experienced running like this since being at school and had to pay to do it. to be fair the marshalls were numerous and very good at times but to be honest I thought this run was dangerous in places and was pleased to finish with both trainers still on. also, the worst "prize" I have received on any run which would have been thrown away but had to keep it out of novelty value. I think the spelling is wrong, am I the only one to notice this ? uffmoor/uffmore, you decide.
In short: very well organised, great marshalling. In full: ok, the scenery on this run is nothing to right home about but the marshalling all the way round was in my opinion top class. flat course so pb's very possible and an excellent start/finish area. plenty of nice touches to the day and a lovely cup of tea and some biscuits at the finish. massive thank-you and congratulations to EVERYONE who made this event so worthwhile. marshalls, you were fantastic.
In short: what a disastrous start/finish In full: good news-now a decent medal and t'shirt. bad news-chaotic start ! firstly, why change the start procedure from previous years on the road outside west park ? if runners can run on this road in the race then why cant we start here. the top end runners were made to run around much slower relay runners and weave in and out to run at their pace. with the amount of runners involved starting areas based on predicted times would be useful. also, on the second lap of the marathon cars are too close to the runners. after over 20 miles dont really like cars within a metre of me !! being a local lad, will always support my local marathon BUT simple improvements are needed. to close, thanks to the marshalls who were very supportive-it is appreciated. Date of review: September 8, 2008