denotes Subscriber-only content | Saturday 21 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  

WIN A PRIZE!

Join Runner's World now

We’re giving away £200 of Asics kit to a new member each month! Sign up and find out more...
why join?  

Members Logon

Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?

Quicklinks

Search this site

New and improved!
 GENERAL RW Jul 05
 

Q+A: Am I too heavy for my height?

Our experts answer real-life questions

Q I weigh 10st 12lb and am 5ft 3in. Am I too heavy for my height?

A The normal height-weight tables are very limited in their ability to assess whether a person is over- or underweight, as they do not take your frame and amount of muscle mass into account, and muscle really is heavier than fat. As a runner, you work the largest muscles in your body, and the more you train, the bigger and heavier your muscles will become.

However, even if your weight is predominantly muscle, it is still advisable to keep it in check, as the more weight you are carrying, the more load goes through your joints, particularly your knees, when running. It is also more of a strain on the body's cardiovascular system. When assessing a person's “normality” for their height, Body Mass Index (BMI) is considered to be the gold standard. It is calculated by dividing your body mass in kilograms by your height in metres squared. Your BMI works out as 26.9, which would be considered to be on the heavy side. A BMI of 19-25 is considered to be the ideal.

Bear in mind that in addition to this index not allowing for a person's increased muscle mass, the population used to research and formulate the equation was not an athletic one.

Nicki de Leon, Physiotherapist and Clinical Director at Sports and Spinal Clinics (Moorgate)


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 18 messages, read more:
amanda lane 
Posted: 21/03/07 13:11:39 39
My god I didn't think there was anyone like me out there. I am weigh exactly the same as you and I am exactly the same height as you. I am a comfortable size 12/14 and yet I feel and know I weigh too much. I have been running now for 5 years and know I have built up a lot of muscle in that time. I eat healthily and sensibly and not only do I run 2 to 3 times in an average week but I also play squash and badminton and go to an aerobics class so ,by rights, I should be a comfortable size 8/10! Even with all of this, I still find it really difficult to lose weight. I cannot even blame chocolate and cake now as I have given all that up for Lent!
Read more...
Related articles:
Q+A: Why have I got an ever-expanding waistline? Subscribers only
Our experts answer real-life questions
Q+A: Am I obese? Subscribers only
Our experts answer real-life questions